Prices verified Aug 4 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
Quick answer
For US shoppers comparing these adhesive-vinyl rolls, ORACAL 651 is listed as a 12-inch by 6-foot matte-black permanent-vinyl roll at $6.88. Cricut Premium is listed as a 4-foot light-blue permanent-vinyl roll at $4.97. Cricut is $1.91 cheaper upfront, but ORACAL lists 2 more feet of roll length and has the slightly higher captured rating: 4.7 stars from 21,518 reviews versus Cricut’s 4.6 stars from 11,748. The rolls also differ in color and finish, so this is not a pure brand comparison. This page does not independently test adhesion, cutting, weeding, color accuracy, residue, outdoor life, or compatibility with a specific machine or surface. Confirm the exact color, finish, dimensions, cutting settings, intended surface, and captured price before ordering. Both primary products were verified in stock in the captured US registry.
ORACAL lists a longer roll and slightly higher rating; Cricut costs $1.91 less and is light blue. Color, finish, dimensions, and machine settings should decide the purchase.
Mubboo Verdict
Winner
ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft
ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft vs Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll, side by side
ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft
Pros:
- Captured price is $6.88
- 12-inch by 6-foot matte-black wording appears in the listing title
- 4.7-star rating from 21,518 captured reviews
Cons (honest weight):
- Higher captured price than Cricut
- Adhesion and cutting behavior were not tested
- Confirm finish, color, and intended surface
Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll
Pros:
- Captured price is $4.97
- 4-foot roll and light-blue wording appear in the listing title
- Lower upfront price than ORACAL
Cons (honest weight):
- Shorter listed roll than ORACAL
- Adhesion and cutting behavior were not tested
- Confirm finish, color, and machine compatibility
Where each one wins
8 dimensions scored head-to-head. ORACAL 651 takes 4; Cricut Premium takes 1.
| Dimension | ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft | Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Captured priceCricut is listed lower. | $6.88 | $4.97 | Cricut Premium |
| Roll lengthORACAL lists 6 feet. | 6 ft | 4 ft | ORACAL 651 |
| WidthORACAL title states 12 inches. | 12 in | Verify | ORACAL 651 |
| RatingORACAL shows the higher rating. | 4.7 | 4.6 | ORACAL 651 |
| Review countORACAL has the larger pool. | 21,518 | 11,748 | ORACAL 651 |
| Color and finishDifferent project preferences. | Matte black | Light blue | Tie |
| Adhesion and cuttingNo controlled test. | Not tested | Not tested | Tie |
| InstructionsVerify live guidance. | Verify | Verify | Tie |
| Overall | 4 wins | 1 win | ORACAL 651 |
Length, color, and price
ORACAL 651 is listed as a 12-inch by 6-foot matte-black roll at $6.88. Cricut Premium is listed as a 4-foot light-blue roll at $4.97. Cricut is $1.91 cheaper upfront, while ORACAL lists 2 more feet of material.
Because the primary rolls differ in both color and finish, the right choice depends on the project. A cheaper roll is not a better value if it is the wrong color, finish, width, or length for the design.
Measure the largest design, add room for alignment and mistakes, and account for waste before deciding whether four or six feet is enough. Roll length is only useful when the width and color also match the project.
Machine and surface checks
Before cutting, verify the live product instructions and your machine’s supported material settings. Test a small piece on the intended surface, especially if the project is difficult to remove or the surface may be damaged.
Surface texture, cleaning, temperature, pressure, and exposure can affect results. Do not assume that “permanent” in a product title means the same removal behavior on every surface.
Price and review evidence
The captured registry shows ORACAL at 4.7 stars from 21,518 reviews and Cricut at 4.6 stars from 11,748 reviews. This is retailer feedback-pool evidence, not a controlled test of adhesion, cutting, weeding, or outdoor life.
Prices and ratings can change with time, color, finish, seller, and package variation. Confirm the exact roll shown at checkout.
What this comparison does not test
No controlled test is included for adhesion strength, clean removal, cutting pressure, weeding difficulty, color accuracy, residue, scratch resistance, weather exposure, or long-term durability. Listing language is not a lab or craft-bench result.
For permanent signage or outdoor work, follow the manufacturer’s live instructions and consider the surface and exposure conditions before committing the full roll.
Who should choose which
Choose ORACAL if you want the longer matte-black roll and slightly higher captured rating. Choose Cricut if the light-blue color and $1.91 lower upfront price fit your project.
The Sooez and Cricut Value alternatives are separate paths with different lengths or colors, not silent replacements for either primary roll.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Budget-first shopping | Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll | Lower captured upfront price. |
| You need more material | ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft | 6-foot listed roll. |
| You need matte black | ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft | Matte-black listing. |
| You need light blue | Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll | Light-blue listing. |
| You prefer the higher rating | ORACAL 651 Permanent Vinyl Matte Black, 12 x 6 ft | Higher captured rating. |
| You are testing a new project | Cricut Premium Permanent Vinyl Light Blue, 4 ft Roll | Lower entry price for a small project. |
Lower captured upfront price.
6-foot listed roll.
Matte-black listing.
Light-blue listing.
Higher captured rating.
Lower entry price for a small project.
What if neither is right?
Sooez Black Permanent Vinyl, 12 x 11 ft
$9.99
The captured registry lists this 12-inch by 11-foot permanent-vinyl alternative in stock; verify finish and cutting compatibility at checkout.
Cricut Value Permanent Vinyl White, 12 x 10 ft
$6.99
The captured registry lists this Cricut value roll in stock at 12 inches by 10 feet; verify color and finish at checkout.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, ORACAL 651 or Cricut Premium vinyl?
ORACAL lists a longer 6-foot matte-black roll and has a slightly higher captured rating. Cricut is $1.91 cheaper and is listed in light blue. Choose by project color, finish, length, and machine settings.
Which adhesive vinyl is cheaper?
The captured registry lists Cricut at $4.97 versus $6.88 for ORACAL. Check the exact color and roll variation at checkout.
Which roll is longer?
ORACAL lists 6 feet; Cricut lists 4 feet.
Can I use either vinyl for any surface?
Do not assume that. Check the live product guidance and test a small piece on the intended surface, especially for permanent projects.
Did this comparison test adhesion or cutting?
No. It compares captured registry and listing evidence and does not include controlled testing of adhesion, cutting, weeding, residue, color accuracy, or outdoor life.
Primary sources: Price, rating, review count, stock, product title, and product image are drawn from captured US registry records for ORACAL 651, Cricut Premium Vinyl, Sooez Black Vinyl, and Cricut Value Vinyl. The titles support the dimensions, color, finish, and format wording quoted here; they do not establish measured adhesion, cutability, weeding, residue, outdoor life, or compatibility with every machine or surface.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Author: Mubboo Editorial Team. Independent US-market consumer research using captured registry records and exact listing information. Last verified: 2026-08-04. No controlled adhesion, cutting, or outdoor testing is claimed.