NICETOWN Blackout Curtains: Which Should You Buy?

Price — Budget pick wins big

The Halloween curtains cost $9.97 to the lined pair's $23.95. That's $13.98 less for two panels—a 58% savings. For a dorm or rental, the savings justify some light leakage.

In daily use, $9.97 feels like a steal. You'll save enough to buy a second set for another window. The lined option costs more but pays off if you need uninterrupted sleep.

Prioritize the budget pair if you have multiple windows to cover. Choose the lined pair if one or two windows are critical for blackout.

Rating — Lined curtains earn higher praise

The NICETOWN 100% Blackout scores 4.8 stars vs 4.6 for the Halloween pair. Across 78,140 reviews, buyers consistently praise its complete light block and noise reduction.

This half-star gap matters. 4.6 is excellent but 4.8 signals near-perfect satisfaction. The lined version's higher rating reflects its specialized performance.

Prioritize the higher rating if you are sensitive to small flaws. Choose the budget pair if price is the primary factor.

Reviews — Halloween curtains have more social proof

The Halloween curtains have 129,939 reviews, the lined pair 78,140. That's 65% more—a massive sample that confirms consistent quality.

More reviews mean fewer hidden surprises. The budget pair's 4.6 average across 130k voices is highly reliable. The lined pair's 78k is still substantial.

Prioritize the budget pair if you value crowd-tested reliability. Choose the lined pair if you trust its higher rating more than volume.

Blackout Level — Lined curtains deliver total darkness

The lined version blocks 100% of light, compared to 85-99% for the Halloween pair. The sewn-in black liner is the key difference. Wirecutter recommends lined curtains for complete room darkening.

In practice, the budget pair turns a bright room into a dim one. The lined pair creates pitch-black even at noon—essential for shift workers or nurseries.

Prioritize the lined pair if you need total darkness. Choose the budget pair if a dark-ish room is sufficient.

Liner — One has it, one doesn't

The Halloween curtains are unlined; the 100% Blackout pair has a black liner. The liner absorbs and blocks light completely, while unlined fabric lets some light through.

Unlined curtains are lighter and easier to wash. Lined curtains are heavier and reduce noise better. The weight difference is noticeable when opening and closing.

Prioritize the lined pair for bedrooms near busy streets. Choose the unlined pair for living rooms where light filtering is fine.

Panels Included — Both come as pairs

Both models include two panels per package. The Halloween version measures 42x63 inches each; the lined version is 52x84 inches each.

The size difference matters. The budget pair fits standard windows up to 84 inches wide (two panels side by side). The lined pair covers 104 inches total width, better for larger windows.

Prioritize the larger panels if you have wide or tall windows. Choose the budget pair for standard 36-48 inch windows.

Best For — Different buyers, different wins

The Halloween curtains are best for budget shoppers; the lined pair for light-sensitive sleepers. This is a tie because both serve their audience well.

If you read in natural light but need darkness at night, the lined pair is worth the extra. If you just need to dim a guest room, save your money.

Prioritize based on your window's sun exposure and your sleep needs. No wrong choice here.

Value — Both are excellent in their tiers

The Halloween curtains offer the best value per dollar at $5 per panel. The lined pair gives the best blackout performance for $12 per panel.

Value depends on your definition. If blackout percentage per dollar matters, the budget pair wins. If absolute darkness per dollar matters, the lined pair is still a bargain.

Prioritize the budget pair if you need to cover many windows. Choose the lined pair if a single window must be completely dark.