Prices verified May 28 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
The Etekcity Smart Scale wins for app experience and display — its Wi-Fi sync and full-color TFT screen justify the $55 premium over the RENPHO. Budget shoppers should grab the RENPHO at $24.99.
The Verdict
Winner
Etekcity Smart Scale
Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight Fat, Digital Weighing Machine for Accurate BMI Muscle Mass Composition vs RENPHO Smart Scale for Body Weight, FSA&HSA Eligible, Bathroom Digital Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Bluetooth, side by side
Pros:
- Wi-Fi automatic sync to cloud for anytime access
- Color TFT display shows 9 metrics without phone
- Alexa voice control compatible
- FSA/HSA eligible
Cons (honest weight):
- Higher price at $79.99
- Requires app for full body composition metrics
Pros:
- Extremely affordable at $24.99
- Syncs with Apple Health, Fitbit, and Google Fit
- Unlimited user profiles for whole family
Cons (honest weight):
- No Wi-Fi, Bluetooth only
- App required to see body fat percentage
Where each one wins
8 dimensions scored head-to-head. Etekcity Smart takes 6; RENPHO Smart takes 2.
| Dimension | Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight Fat, Digital Weighing Machine for Accurate BMI Muscle Mass Composition | RENPHO Smart Scale for Body Weight, FSA&HSA Eligible, Bathroom Digital Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Bluetooth | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceRENPHO is $55 cheaper, offering excellent value for budget shoppers. | $79.99 | $24.99 | RENPHO Smart |
| Body MetricsEtekcity tracks one additional metric (heart rate) for a more complete picture. | 14 metrics | 13 metrics | Etekcity Smart |
| ConnectivityEtekcity's Wi-Fi syncs automatically to the cloud; RENPHO requires phone proximity. | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Bluetooth only | Etekcity Smart |
| DisplayEtekcity's TFT shows 9 metrics without a phone; RENPHO shows only weight. | Color TFT | LED | Etekcity Smart |
| App EcosystemBoth sync widely, but Etekcity adds Alexa and MyFitnessPal support. | Apple Health, Google Fit, Fitbit, MyFitnessPal, Samsung Health, Alexa | Apple Health, Fitbit, Google Fit | Etekcity Smart |
| RatingEtekcity has a slightly higher rating and more reviews. | 4.7 stars (346,480 reviews) | 4.6 stars (333,929 reviews) | Etekcity Smart |
| Review CountEtekcity has about 12,500 more verified reviews. | 346,480 | 333,929 | Etekcity Smart |
| ValueRENPHO offers the best metrics-per-dollar ratio. | 14 metrics for $79.99 | 13 metrics for $24.99 | RENPHO Smart |
| Overall | 6 wins | 2 wins | Etekcity Smart |
Price — RENPHO wins for value
The RENPHO costs $24.99, a full $55 less than the Etekcity. For budget shoppers, this is the clear winner.
In daily use, that $55 buys a lot of groceries or gym gear. You get reliable body composition tracking without breaking the bank.
Choose RENPHO if price is your top priority. You still get 13 metrics and app sync.
Body Metrics — Etekcity offers one more data point
The Etekcity tracks 14 body metrics including heart rate; RENPHO tracks 13. The extra metric gives a slightly more detailed health snapshot.
For most users, 13 metrics are plenty. Heart rate on a scale is convenient but not essential.
Fitness enthusiasts who want every data point should lean Etekcity. Casual users notice no difference.
Connectivity — Wi-Fi gives Etekcity the edge
Etekcity syncs via Wi-Fi automatically to the cloud; RENPHO uses Bluetooth only. Wi-Fi means data uploads even when your phone isn't nearby.
Bluetooth requires opening the app near the scale. This becomes tedious for daily tracking.
If you want seamless, hands-free logging, choose Etekcity. RENPHO works fine if you always have your phone handy.
Display — Etekcity's TFT is a standout
The Etekcity has a color TFT screen that shows 9 metrics without needing a phone. The RENPHO has a basic LED display showing only weight.
Seeing body fat, muscle mass, and BMI on the scale is motivating. No app required for a quick check.
Tech enthusiasts will appreciate the Etekcity's visual feedback. The RENPHO's LED is fine for weight-only users.
App Ecosystem — Both are strong, but Etekcity adds Alexa
Both scales sync with major health platforms: Apple Health, Google Fit, Fitbit. Etekcity also works with MyFitnessPal and Alexa.
Alexa voice integration lets you ask 'Alexa, ask VeSync how much weight I've lost this week.' A nice motivator.
If you're in the Apple Health or Fitbit ecosystem, both work well. Alexa users should pick the Etekcity.
Rating — Etekcity edges ahead
Etekcity has 4.7 stars from 346,480 reviews; RENPHO has 4.6 from 333,929. Both are excellent ratings.
Reviewers consistently praise Etekcity's build quality and app experience. RENPHO gets high marks for affordability and simplicity.
Trust either scale for reliable performance. The rating difference is small.
Review Count — Both are among the most-reviewed scales
With over 680,000 combined reviews, these are proven products. Etekcity has about 12,500 more reviews than RENPHO.
No single model dominates; both have strong track records. This indicates consistent quality across batches.
Buy confidently from either brand. You're getting a popular, well-tested product.
Value — RENPHO delivers the most per dollar
RENPHO offers 13 metrics for $24.99 — about $1.92 per metric. Etekcity costs $79.99 for 14 metrics, or $5.71 per metric.
If you're counting pennies, RENPHO is the clear choice. You sacrifice Wi-Fi and a nicer display but save $55.
Budget-conscious households should choose RENPHO. Premium buyers willing to pay for convenience should pick Etekcity.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Budget-conscious shopper | RENPHO Smart Scale for Body Weight, FSA&HSA Eligible, Bathroom Digital Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Bluetooth | RENPHO delivers 13 metrics at $24.99 — unbeatable value. |
| Tech enthusiast who loves gadgets | Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight Fat, Digital Weighing Machine for Accurate BMI Muscle Mass Composition | Wi-Fi sync, TFT display, and Alexa voice control make Etekcity the fun choice. |
| Fitness tracker with Apple Watch | Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight Fat, Digital Weighing Machine for Accurate BMI Muscle Mass Composition | Seamless sync with Apple Health and Workouts; Wi-Fi ensures data updates automatically. |
| Family with multiple users | RENPHO Smart Scale for Body Weight, FSA&HSA Eligible, Bathroom Digital Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Bluetooth | RENPHO supports unlimited user profiles, perfect for a household. |
| Senior or less tech-savvy user | RENPHO Smart Scale for Body Weight, FSA&HSA Eligible, Bathroom Digital Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Bluetooth | Lower price, simple LED display, and Bluetooth only — less complexity. |
| Gym enthusiast wanting segmental analysis | Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight Fat, Digital Weighing Machine for Accurate BMI Muscle Mass Composition | Etekcity's 14 metrics include heart rate and more detailed breakdowns. |
RENPHO delivers 13 metrics at $24.99 — unbeatable value.
Wi-Fi sync, TFT display, and Alexa voice control make Etekcity the fun choice.
Seamless sync with Apple Health and Workouts; Wi-Fi ensures data updates automatically.
RENPHO supports unlimited user profiles, perfect for a household.
Lower price, simple LED display, and Bluetooth only — less complexity.
Etekcity's 14 metrics include heart rate and more detailed breakdowns.
What if neither is right?
Etekcity Upgraded Smart Scale (B0DJX4B216)
$35.99
A middle ground: Bluetooth only but with offline mode and 13 metrics at $35.99.
FITINDEX Smart Scale (B078HW8BPY)
$19.99
Another budget option with 13 metrics, Bluetooth, and baby mode for pet owners.
INEVIFIT Premium Bathroom Scale (B07L28V39Q)
$69.99
A premium non-smart scale with 4.8 stars — for those who only need weight.
Frequently Asked Questions
Etekcity vs RENPHO: which scale is better?
The Etekcity is better for app experience, Wi-Fi sync, and a color display. The RENPHO is better for budget shoppers — it costs $55 less and still offers 13 body metrics.
Is the Etekcity worth the extra $55?
Yes, if you value Wi-Fi cloud sync, a color TFT display that shows metrics without a phone, and Alexa voice control. Budget shoppers may prefer the RENPHO's excellent value.
Both scales are FSA/HSA eligible — is that easy to use?
Yes, both scales are FSA/HSA eligible. You can purchase with your health savings card on Amazon — just check your plan's coverage.
Do I need an app to see body fat on these scales?
The Etekcity shows up to 9 metrics on its TFT display without a phone. The RENPHO shows only weight on the display — you need the app for body fat, BMI, and other metrics.
How accurate are these body fat scales?
Both use bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) and are accurate for tracking trends over time. For exact body fat percentage, DEXA scans are more precise, but these scales are consistent enough for home use.
Can multiple users share the scale?
Yes, both scales support unlimited user profiles. The RENPHO app auto-recognizes users based on weight, while Etekcity requires manual selection via the app.
We analyzed Amazon verified-buyer reviews (680,000+ total) and manufacturer specifications to compare these two top-selling smart scales. Prices update weekly from Amazon.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team — independent US-market consumer research. Picks reflect verified buyer data and manufacturer specs.