Prices verified May 28 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
The Gas One GS-3400P wins for most campers — dual fuel flexibility and higher 10,000 BTU output justify the $5 premium over the butane-only model.
The Verdict
Winner
Gas One GS-3400P
Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove vs Gas One Portable Butane Camping Stove with Case, side by side
Pros:
- Dual fuel compatible with propane or butane
- Automatic piezo ignition for easy lighting
- Pressure sensor safety ejection system
- Includes carrying case and regulator
Cons (honest weight):
- Heavier than some butane-only models
- No independent safety certification (not CSA approved)
Pros:
- Very affordable at under $25
- CSA certified for safety
- Quiet operation
- Compact with carrying case
Cons (honest weight):
- Butane only, less common than propane
- Lower BTU output than dual-fuel competitor
Where each one wins
9 dimensions scored head-to-head. Gas One takes 4; Gas One takes 3.
| Dimension | Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove | Gas One Portable Butane Camping Stove with Case | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceThe butane stove is $5 cheaper. | $29.99 | $24.99 | Gas One |
| Fuel TypeDual fuel gives you backup options at crowded campsites. | Propane and butane | Butane only | Gas One |
| BTU OutputThe GS-3400P boils water about 25% faster. | 10,000 BTU | 7,650 BTU | Gas One |
| WeightBoth weigh the same, easy to pack in the car. | 3.1 lbs | 3.1 lbs | Tie |
| Auto IgnitionBoth have automatic ignition, no matches needed. | Yes (piezo) | Yes (piezo) | Tie |
| Safety CertificationsOnly the butane stove has independent safety certification. | Not listed | CSA approved | Gas One |
| Best ForDual fuel appeals to a wider range of campers. | Dual‑fuel flexibility | Budget butane use | Gas One |
| RatingThe butane stove scores slightly higher customer satisfaction. | 4.6 | 4.7 | Gas One |
| Included AccessoriesThe GS-3400P includes a propane regulator for dual-fuel use. | Carrying case, regulator | Carrying case | Gas One |
| Overall | 4 wins | 3 wins | Gas One |
Fuel Type — Dual‑Fuel Wins
The GS-3400P runs on both propane and butane canisters. This matters when you arrive at a campsite that only sells one type. The butane stove is limited to 8 oz butane canisters, which are less common at gas stations than propane cylinders.
For most campers, flexibility is a real advantage. You can grab whatever fuel is available without worrying about compatibility. Car campers and tailgaters will particularly appreciate this.
BTU Output — Higher Heat for Faster Cooking
The GS-3400P delivers 10,000 BTU vs 7,650 BTU. That means boiling water about 25% faster — a big deal when you're hungry at camp.
The butane stove handles most meals fine, but it struggles in windy conditions or when cooking for a group. If you often cook for more than two people, the extra power is worth the $5 premium.
Safety Certifications — CSA Certified Peace of Mind
The butane stove is CSA approved; the dual‑fuel model is not. CSA (Canadian Standards Association) testing covers fuel leakage, overheating, and structural integrity.
For safety‑conscious buyers, this certification adds value. The GS-3400P still has a pressure sensor ejection system, but lacks third‑party validation.
Price — A $5 Gap with Different Priorities
The butane stove costs $24.99, the dual‑fuel $29.99. That $5 difference is tiny for most people, but it buys you fuel flexibility and a regulator.
If you already own butane canisters, save the $5. If you're starting from scratch, the dual‑fuel is arguably the better investment because you can use the cheaper propane cylinders that last longer.
Portability and Weight — Identical
Both stoves weigh 3.1 lbs and are nearly identical in size. Each comes with a carrying case, so they pack easily in a trunk or RV bay.
Neither is backpack‑worthy, but for car camping and picnics, they're perfectly portable.
Customer Ratings — Nearly Tied
The butane stove scores 4.7 stars vs 4.6 for the GS-3400P. Both are among the top‑rated in their category. The butane stove has slightly fewer reviews (8,200 vs 14,800), but the ratings are consistent.
Buyers praise the dual‑fuel for flexibility and the butane for quiet operation. Neither has widespread complaints about reliability.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Weekend car camper | Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove | Dual fuel gives you options when nearest store is out of butane. |
| Budget backpacker with butane stock | Gas One Portable Butane Camping Stove with Case | Save $5 and use the canisters you already have. |
| Family cookouts at the park | Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove | Higher BTU handles larger pots and faster meals. |
| Emergency kit | Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove | Propane availability is more reliable during weather events. |
| Tailgating | Gas One GS-3400P Propane or Butane Stove Dual Fuel Stove | Flexible fuel and higher heat for burgers and hot dogs. |
| Solo camper who uses butane | Gas One Portable Butane Camping Stove with Case | Quiet, safe, and $5 cheaper — ideal for simple meals. |
Dual fuel gives you options when nearest store is out of butane.
Save $5 and use the canisters you already have.
Higher BTU handles larger pots and faster meals.
Propane availability is more reliable during weather events.
Flexible fuel and higher heat for burgers and hot dogs.
Quiet, safe, and $5 cheaper — ideal for simple meals.
What if neither is right?
Coleman BottleTop Propane Stove
$39.99
Best for campfire cooking with 10,000 BTU and wind baffles.
Coleman Triton 2-Burner Propane Stove
$89.99
Best for family camping with 22,000 total BTU and two burners.
Fire-Maple Fixed Star 1 Backpacking Stove System
$49.95
Best for ultralight backpacking at 18 oz with integrated pot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Gas One GS-3400P vs Gas One Portable Butane Stove: which is better?
The GS-3400P is better for most campers because it runs on both propane and butane, offering fuel flexibility. It also has a higher BTU output (10,000 vs 7,650) for faster cooking. The butane stove is better if you only use butane canisters and want to save $5.
Is the GS-3400P worth the extra $5?
Yes, if you value the ability to use either propane or butane. Propane is more widely available and cheaper per canister. The higher BTU output also reduces cooking time. For most campers, the $5 premium is well worth it.
Can I use propane with the butane stove?
No, the Gas One Portable Butane Stove is designed exclusively for 8 oz butane canisters. Attempting to use propane could damage the stove and is unsafe. Stick to butane or choose the dual‑fuel model if you need propane compatibility.
Which stove is more portable?
Both weigh the same (3.1 lbs) and are nearly identical in size. Each comes with a carrying case, making them equally portable for car camping. Neither is suitable for backpacking due to weight, but they're fine for trunk or RV storage.
Researched across Amazon's verified buyer data, manufacturer specifications, and buyer discussion. Prices update weekly from Amazon.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team. Picks based on verified user reviews and manufacturer specs. Prices update weekly from Amazon.