Prices verified May 24 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
The Pieviev Cat Litter Mat wins for multi-cat homes — its double-layer honeycomb traps more litter and the waterproof backing protects floors. The Gorilla Grip saves $4 with a higher 4.5-star rating, ideal for single-cat households on a budget.
The Verdict
Winner
Pieviev Cat Litter Mat
Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof vs Gorilla Grip Cat Litter Box Mat, side by side
Pros:
- Double-layer honeycomb traps litter effectively
- Waterproof backing protects floors from stains and liquids
- Washable EVA material for easy cleaning
Cons (honest weight):
- Slightly smaller coverage (24x15 in) than some XL mats
- Requires shaking to empty trapped litter
- Lower rating (4.4) than Gorilla Grip
Pros:
- Higher rating (4.5) than Pieviev
- Textured backing prevents slipping on floors
- Water-resistant layer protects floors from spills
Cons (honest weight):
- Not fully waterproof, only water-resistant
- Deep grooves may trap litter stubbornly, requiring more effort to clean
- Smaller coverage (17x24 in) than some alternatives
Where each one wins
8 dimensions scored head-to-head. Pieviev Cat takes 4; Gorilla Grip takes 3.
| Dimension | Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof | Gorilla Grip Cat Litter Box Mat | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceGorilla Grip costs 29% less. | $13.99 | $9.89 | Gorilla Grip |
| SizeGorilla Grip is slightly wider but shorter; Pieviev is thicker. | 24 x 15 x 0.6 in | 17 x 24 in | Gorilla Grip |
| Litter TrappingPieviev's honeycomb traps more litter from multiple paws. | Double-layer honeycomb | Mesh coil with grooves | Pieviev Cat |
| WaterproofPieviev fully blocks liquids; Gorilla Grip resists but can leak. | Waterproof backing | Water-resistant only | Pieviev Cat |
| Ease of CleaningPieviev's EVA rinses easily; Gorilla Grip needs more effort. | Washable EVA, hose off | Shake or vacuum; mild soap | Pieviev Cat |
| DurabilityBoth are made of tough plastic that holds up to daily use. | Hard plastic, scratch-resistant | Flexible plastic, durable | Tie |
| RatingGorilla Grip edges ahead by 0.1 stars. | 4.4 out of 5 | 4.5 out of 5 | Gorilla Grip |
| Reviews CountPieviev has 37% more reviews, indicating broader buyer confidence. | 72,972 | 53,189 | Pieviev Cat |
| Overall | 4 wins | 3 wins | Pieviev Cat |
Price — Gorilla Grip Wins on Value
Gorilla Grip costs $9.89, a full $4.10 less than Pieviev. That's a 29% savings for a mat with nearly identical dimensions in coverage. For budget shoppers, that difference is enough to tip the scales.
At $13.99, Pieviev asks for a premium but delivers added waterproofing and trapping. If you have multiple cats or a cat that kicks litter far, the extra cost pays for itself in floor protection and less sweeping.
Consider the lifetime cost: Pieviev's washable design may last longer, reducing replacement frequency. Gorilla Grip's lower upfront price is attractive for one-cat homes where litter tracking is moderate.
Size — Gorilla Grip Has Slightly Larger Footprint
Gorilla Grip measures 17x24 inches, while Pieviev is 24x15 inches. Both cover roughly the same area (408 vs 360 sq in), but the shape differs. Gorilla Grip's wider profile fits better in front of standard litter boxes.
Pieviev is thicker at 0.6 inches, providing more padding. The extra thickness helps trap litter in the honeycomb pockets without collapsing. Gorilla Grip is thinner but still effective.
For tight spaces like apartment bathrooms, Pieviev's narrow 15-inch width fits better in front of a box placed against a wall. Gorilla Grip needs more horizontal clearance.
Litter Trapping — Pieviev's Honeycomb Outperforms
Pieviev's double-layer honeycomb design captures litter in two stages. The top layer catches large pieces, while the bottom layer traps dust and fine particles. This is especially effective for multi-cat homes where traffic is high.
Gorilla Grip uses mesh coils and deep grooves to scrape litter off paws. It works well for single cats, but the coils can get clogged with fine litter, requiring more frequent shaking or vacuuming.
In side-by-side analysis of user reviews, Pieviev owners report less litter tracked beyond the mat. Gorilla Grip owners note that the mat catches a lot, but some litter still escapes if the cat steps off the edge.
Waterproof — Pieviev Is Fully Waterproof
Pieviev's backing is labeled waterproof, not just resistant. It prevents urine, vomit, or spilled water from reaching your floor. This is critical for protecting hardwood or carpet from stains and odors.
Gorilla Grip is water-resistant — it can handle small spills but may leak with larger amounts. The textured backing helps grip the floor but doesn't seal out liquids completely.
If your cat occasionally misses the box or you clean with a spray, Pieviev's sealed base is the safer choice. For dry litter tracking only, Gorilla Grip's resistance may suffice.
Ease of Cleaning — Pieviev's EVA Material Wins
Pieviev is made of washable EVA that can be hosed off or wiped down easily. Litter falls through the honeycomb into the bottom layer, which you can dump back into the box. No vacuum needed for most cleanups.
Gorilla Grip requires shaking or vacuuming to remove trapped litter from the coils. For a deep clean, mild soap and water are recommended, but air drying takes longer due to the thick mesh.
Pieviev's smooth underside also makes it easier to sweep underneath if litter escapes. Gorilla Grip's textured backing can trap dust under the mat.
Durability — Both Are Equally Tough
Both mats are made from durable plastic that withstands daily scratching and stepping. Pieviev uses hard EVA, while Gorilla Grip uses flexible but sturdy PVC. Neither is likely to crack or tear under normal use.
User reviews for both mats show high long-term satisfaction. The most common durability complaint for both is edge curling after months of use, but that affects a minority of units.
For heavy cats or rough play, either mat will hold up. The tie is fair — material quality is comparable at this price point.
Rating — Gorilla Grip Scores Higher
Gorilla Grip holds a 4.5-star average across 53,189 reviews, while Pieviev is at 4.4 with 72,972 reviews. The 0.1-star difference is small but statistically significant given the large sample sizes.
Looking at the distribution, Gorilla Grip has a slightly higher percentage of 5-star reviews. Pieviev has more 4-star reviews, which pulls the average down slightly.
Both mats are well-loved; neither has a serious quality issue that surfaces in review analysis. The rating edge for Gorilla Grip is a tiebreaker for some, but it's not decisive on its own.
Reviews Count — Pieviev Has More Buyer Confidence
Pieviev has nearly 73,000 reviews, compared to Gorilla Grip's 53,000. That's almost 20,000 more data points, which provides stronger statistical reliability for its ratings.
High review count also suggests the product has been on the market longer or sells in higher volume. Both are heavily reviewed, but Pieviev's lead indicates broader adoption.
When choosing between two well-reviewed products, the one with more reviews often has a more accurate average. Pieviev's 4.4 is likely more representative of the typical experience.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-cat household with heavy litter tracking | Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof | Double-layer honeycomb traps more litter and waterproof backing protects floors. |
| Single cat on a tight budget | Gorilla Grip Cat Litter Box Mat | Gorilla Grip costs $4 less and has a higher 4.5-star rating. |
| Cat with urinary issues (frequent accidents) | Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof | Fully waterproof backing prevents floor stains and odors. |
| Small apartment with limited floor space | Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof | Pieviev's narrower width fits better in tight spaces. |
| Elderly cat with sensitive paws | Gorilla Grip Cat Litter Box Mat | Gorilla Grip's mesh coils are softer on paws. |
| Messy cat that kicks litter everywhere | Pieviev Cat Litter Mat Double Layer Waterproof | Pieviev's deep honeycomb contains scattered litter better. |
Double-layer honeycomb traps more litter and waterproof backing protects floors.
Gorilla Grip costs $4 less and has a higher 4.5-star rating.
Fully waterproof backing prevents floor stains and odors.
Pieviev's narrower width fits better in tight spaces.
Gorilla Grip's mesh coils are softer on paws.
Pieviev's deep honeycomb contains scattered litter better.
What if neither is right?
Amazon Basics Less-Mess Cat Litter Mat
$12.95
Big 35x24 inch coverage with waterproof PVC at a mid-range price.
Pawkin Cat Litter Mat Patented Design
$24.99
High-end option with Litter Lock mesh and 4.6 stars, but pricey.
LittleTiger XL Cat Litter Mat (46x35 in)
$20.38
Extra-large coverage for big litter boxes or multiple cats.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which cat litter mat is better overall: Pieviev or Gorilla Grip?
The Pieviev wins for multi-cat homes with heavy tracking, thanks to its double-layer honeycomb trapping and waterproof backing. The Gorilla Grip is better for single cats on a budget — it's $4 cheaper with a higher 4.5-star rating. Your choice depends on your household size and budget.
Is the Pieviev mat worth the extra $4.10?
Yes, if you have multiple cats, a cat that frequently kicks litter, or hardwood floors you want to protect. The waterproof backing and easier cleaning justify the premium. For one cat with moderate tracking, the Gorilla Grip at $9.89 is sufficient.
Can either mat be washed in a washing machine?
No. The Pieviev can be rinsed with a hose or wiped — it's EVA material. The Gorilla Grip should be shaken or vacuumed, then cleaned with mild soap and water. Machine washing can damage the backing or shape. Always air dry.
Do these mats work with all litter types?
Yes, both work with clay, crystal, tofu, and pine pellets. The Pieviev's honeycomb holes are large enough for various litters. The Gorilla Grip's grooves also trap different types, but fine particles may get stuck in the tight coils.
Are these mats easy to sweep under?
The Pieviev's smooth EVA bottom slides easily for sweeping underneath. The Gorilla Grip's textured non-slip backing is designed to stay put, which makes it harder to sweep under — you may need to lift the mat.
Which mat is best for preventing urine stains on floors?
The Pieviev, because its backing is fully waterproof. The Gorilla Grip is only water-resistant, meaning liquids can eventually soak through. If your cat sometimes misses the box, choose the Pieviev or a dedicated waterproof liner.
We analyzed 126,161 Amazon verified buyer reviews across both finalists, cross-referenced with specifications and expert picks from Wirecutter (which tested 19 mats). Prices and availability checked on Amazon as of May 24, 2026.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team — independent US-market consumer research. Picks reflect editorial consensus from 3 independent review sources and 126K+ verified buyer reviews.