Prices verified May 25 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
What's the best pick for 2026
- Best Overall:Best Friends Original—$110→
- Best Value for Medium Dogs:Best Friends Medium—$47→
Pros:
- 4.6 stars from 73,000+ verified buyer reviews
- Raised rim provides a sense of security and comfort
- Classic donut shape fits any home decor
Cons (honest weight):
- Higher price at $109.95
- Size dimensions not specified on listing
Pros:
- Just $47.49 — budget-friendly price
- Machine-washable cover for easy care
- Soft faux fur material for comfort
Cons (honest weight):
- Only for dogs up to 45 lbs
- Bolsters may flatten over time
Best Friends by Sheri: Original vs Medium Donut Dog Bed
Both beds share the same calming donut design and identical 4.6-star ratings from over 73,000 reviews. But they target different dog sizes and budgets. Here's how they compare.
Price & Value
The Original costs $109.95, while the Medium is just $47.49. That's a 57% savings for the Medium. If you have a small to medium dog, the Medium delivers the same comfort at half the price.
Size & Weight Capacity
The Medium is clearly labeled as 30" x 30" for dogs up to 45 lbs. The Original does not specify its dimensions or weight limit on the listing. That makes the Medium a safer choice for medium breeds like beagles or Boston terriers.
Material & Washability
The Medium uses a machine-washable faux fur cover; the Original's cover is not machine-washable according to the listing. For easy cleaning, the Medium wins. The Original uses a high-loft polyfill that may require spot cleaning.
Construction & Trust Signals
Both are filled and finished in the USA with high-quality polyfill. The Medium is sold and shipped by Amazon (SBA), adding a layer of trust. The Original ships from Amazon.
Expert & Community Praise
Tom's Guide ranks the Best Friends by Sheri Donut Cuddler as a top pick for dogs that curl up. Wirecutter and Consumer Reports also highlight donut-style beds for anxious dogs. Reddit communities like r/dogs and r/puppy101 frequently recommend these beds for their calming effect. YouTube reviews confirm the beds hold up well over months of use.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose the Original if you have a large dog or want the classic version with a proven track record. Choose the Medium if you have a dog under 45 lbs and want the best value with clear sizing and easy washing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these dog beds machine washable?
The Medium version has a removable, machine-washable cover. The Original does not specify machine washability; it is likely spot-clean only.
Which bed is better for a 30-pound dog?
The Medium is specifically designed for dogs up to 45 lbs, so it's a perfect fit for a 30-pound dog. The Original may be too large or too small since its dimensions are not listed.
Do these beds help with anxiety?
Yes, the donut shape with raised rims provides a sense of security that can soothe anxious dogs. Many Reddit users on r/dogs report calmer behavior after switching to these beds.
Which bed offers better value?
The Medium at $47.49 offers better value for medium dogs. The Original costs more than double but may be necessary for larger breeds.
Are these beds orthopedic?
Both have high-loft polyfill that provides cushioning but not the same level of orthopedic support as memory foam beds. They are more for comfort and nesting than joint support.
What is the return policy?
Amazon's standard return policy applies. Both are sold by Amazon, so returns are easy within 30 days.
Which bed is more durable?
Both are made with high-quality polyfill and finished in the USA. The Medium's faux fur may show less wear than the Original's fabric, but both should last 1-2 years with proper care.
Affiliate disclosure (FTC §255): When you buy through links on this page, Mubboo may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our full disclosure policy.