Outland Living 19-Inch vs. 24-Inch: Which Propane Fire Pit Fits Your Outdoor Setup?

Price — 19-inch saves $35

The 19-inch costs $124.97, $35 less than the 24-inch at $159.97. That gap buys a carry kit and saves weight.

Budget buyers should choose the smaller model. You sacrifice flame area but gain portability. The 24-inch costs more for a larger bowl and cover, but both share the same burner.

For occasional backyard use, the 19-inch is enough. If you host often, the $35 premium for the 24-inch may be justified.

Diameter — 24-inch wins for space

The 24-inch diameter (24 inches) heats a wider radius. It accommodates 6-8 people comfortably, while the 19-inch fits 4-5.

For large patio gatherings, the 24-inch is better. The flame is more visible from afar, creating a centerpiece. Conversely, the 19-inch is cozier for small groups.

Both bowls are shallow (11-13 inches high). The 24-inch provides more surface area for heat distribution, though the BTU output is identical.

BTU — Tie

Both models output 58,000 BTUs, enough to warm a standard patio. The flame height is adjustable via the regulator. Heat coverage depends on diameter: the larger bowl disperses heat sideways more effectively.

In wind, the 24-inch's larger flame is less affected. Torch-like flames in the 19-inch may flicker more in breezy conditions. For windy patios, the bigger model holds an edge.

Weight — 19-inch by 11 pounds

The 19-inch weighs 23 pounds, the 24-inch weighs 34 pounds. The difference is significant for anyone loading gear into a trunk or RV.

Carrying a 34-pound fire pit down a campsite path is doable but annoying. The 19-inch with its carry kit is effortless. For tailgating, the lighter option wins hands down.

If you rarely move your fire pit, weight is irrelevant. The 24-inch still has handles but no dedicated carry kit.

Portability — 19-inch includes carry kit

The 19-inch comes with a cover+carry kit; the 24-inch includes only a cover. The carry kit has a padded strap that makes transport truly portable.

For campers and RV travelers, this is a major advantage. The 24-inch is considered "portable" but is not designed for frequent toting. The 19-inch is the clear choice for mobility.

Both use standard 20-lb propane tanks, widely available. The 19-inch's stabilizer ring keeps the tank secure during transport.

Smokeless — Tie

Both models feature smokeless technology using secondary combustion. Air intakes along the rim mix oxygen with smoke, producing cleaner flames.

Users report minimal smoke with dry propane, but wind can blow smoke sideways. In calm conditions, both perform equally well. The 24-inch's larger flame may produce slightly more heat, reducing condensation smoke in cool evenings.

Rating — Tie at 4.8 stars

Both units average 4.8 stars from thousands of reviews. The 19-inch has 17,731 reviews, the 24-inch has 9,393. This indicates wide satisfaction.

Common praise: easy setup, clean burn, sturdy build. Complaints: manual ignition, propane tank not included. Both share the same minor drawbacks.

Reliability appears identical across sizes. The 19-inch's higher review count gives it a larger data set but does not compromise the 24-inch's quality.

Reviews Count — 19-inch leads

The 19-inch has 17,731 Amazon verified reviews; the 24-inch has 9,393. The smaller model is significantly more purchased and reviewed.

This suggests broader market trust and longer track record. The 19-inch was launched earlier and remains the best-selling Outland fire pit. The 24-inch is a newer, larger variant.

For risk-averse buyers, the 19-inch offers more user feedback. But both score 4.8 stars, so quality is consistent.