Prices verified Aug 12 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
Quick answer
Our comparison pits the value-priced bullet ice maker against the premium nugget ice machine to help you choose. The Frigidaire produces 26 lbs of bullet ice per day with 7-minute cycles. It has a 4.4-star rating from 16,877 reviews. It's compact at 12x11x14.5 inches and uses 105W. Its main drawbacks are no self-cleaning and ice that melts quickly if not transferred. The EUHOMY makes 34 lbs of chewable nugget ice daily, with first batch in 6 minutes. It rates 4.1 stars from 16,693 reviews. It features self-cleaning, a removable top cover, and extremely low 15.6W power consumption. Its footprint is smaller (11.6x9.5x13 inches) despite higher capacity. The trade-off is a $92 higher price. For budget buyers, the Frigidaire is the obvious choice: reliable bullet ice at a steal. For those who love soft, chewable ice and want easy maintenance, the EUHOMY justifies its premium with superior ice quality and energy efficiency. Both are sold by Amazon and well-reviewed. Consider the alternatives: Frigidaire's black stainless model ($70) offers the same performance in a sleeker look, while EUHOMY's bullet ice maker ($90) adds auto-cleaning to the budget-friendly category.
The Frigidaire wins for budget buyers — $69.99 for 26 lbs of bullet ice daily. Nugget lovers should grab the EUHOMY for chewable ice and self-cleaning at $136.77.
Mubboo Verdict
Winner
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker vs EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle, side by side
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker
Pros:
- Produces 26 lbs of ice daily for $69.99
- Fast 7-minute cycle per batch
- Transparent window for easy monitoring
Cons (honest weight):
- No self-cleaning function
- Ice melts quickly without storage freezer
EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle
Pros:
- Nugget ice in just 6 minutes
- 34 lbs daily capacity for parties
- Self-cleaning function for easy maintenance
Cons (honest weight):
- Higher price at $136.77
- Larger footprint 11.6"D x 9.5"W
Where each one wins
9 dimensions scored head-to-head. FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK takes 3; EUHOMY Nugget takes 5.
| Dimension | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceFrigidaire costs $92 less, a clear win for budget shoppers. | $69.99 | $136.77 | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK |
| Ice TypeNugget ice is softer and more fun to chew; bullet ice is standard. | Bullet | Nugget (chewable) | EUHOMY Nugget |
| Daily CapacityEUHOMY makes 8 more lbs daily, better for parties. | 26 lbs | 34 lbs | EUHOMY Nugget |
| First Batch TimeBoth produce ice fast; difference is negligible. | 7 min | 6 min | Tie |
| Self-CleaningEUHOMY's self-cleaning is a major convenience win. | No | Yes | EUHOMY Nugget |
| Customer RatingFrigidaire has a slightly higher customer rating. | 4.4 | 4.1 | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK |
| Review CountFrigidaire has a few more reviews, both are well-reviewed. | 16,877 | 16,693 | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK |
| DimensionsEUHOMY takes up less counter space despite higher capacity. | 12"D x 11"W x 14.5"H | 11.6"D x 9.5"W x 13"H | EUHOMY Nugget |
| WattageEUHOMY uses only 15.6W vs 105W, dramatically more energy-efficient. | 105 W | 15.6 W | EUHOMY Nugget |
| Overall | 3 wins | 5 wins | EUHOMY Nugget |
Price: Frigidaire wins for the wallet
The Frigidaire is $69.99, while the EUHOMY is $136.77 — a $66.78 gap. That's more than double the cost for the EUHOMY.
For budget shoppers, the Frigidaire leaves room for a bag of ice or two. The EUHOMY's premium buys nugget ice and self-cleaning.
Buy the Frigidaire if you're on a tight budget. The EUHOMY only makes sense if you value the extra features.
Ice Type: Nugget wins for texture
The Frigidaire makes standard bullet ice; the EUHOMY makes soft, chewable nugget ice. Nugget ice is softer and absorbs drink flavors less.
Bullet ice is fine for most drinks but doesn't have the chew factor. Nugget ice is a treat for iced coffee, smoothies, and snacking.
Choose the EUHOMY if you love Sonic-style ice. The Frigidaire works for everyday needs.
Daily Capacity: EUHOMY pumps out more
The EUHOMY makes 34 lbs per day vs the Frigidaire's 26 lbs — an 8 lb lead. That's roughly 30% more ice daily.
For parties or heavy use, the extra capacity matters. For a couple or small household, 26 lbs is plenty.
Party hosts should lean toward the EUHOMY. For occasional use, save money with the Frigidaire.
Self-Cleaning: A major convenience difference
The EUHOMY has a self-cleaning function; the Frigidaire requires manual cleaning. Just hold a button for 3 seconds to start a 15-minute clean cycle.
Manual cleaning involves draining via a plug and wiping down. It's not hard, but it's extra effort.
If you hate maintaining appliances, the EUHOMY is the clear choice. The Frigidaire is fine if you don't mind occasional scrubbing.
Customer Ratings: Frigidaire edges ahead
Frigidaire holds a 4.4-star average vs EUHOMY's 4.1 from similar review counts. Both are highly rated, but users praise Frigidaire's reliability.
EUHOMY reviews mention the fun of nugget ice, with some complaints about noise. Frigidaire owners consistently note ease of use.
For a proven track record, the Frigidaire wins on ratings. The EUHOMY is still well-liked but slightly less consistent.
Dimensions: EUHOMY fits smaller spaces
Despite higher capacity, the EUHOMY has a smaller footprint: 11.6"D x 9.5"W vs 12"D x 11"W. It's also shorter (13" vs 14.5").
This is surprising — the EUHOMY packs more ice production into a tighter package. It fits better on cramped counters.
If counter space is tight, the EUHOMY is the smarter fit. The Frigidaire still fits standard counters but takes more room.
Energy Efficiency: EUHOMY sips power
The EUHOMY uses just 15.6W compared to the Frigidaire's 105W — a 7x difference. Over a year, this could save $10-15 on electricity.
Both use compressors, but the EUHOMY's is remarkably efficient. It also runs quietly, under 50 dB.
Energy-conscious buyers should go with the EUHOMY. The Frigidaire still costs little to run, but the EUHOMY is dramatically greener.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Budget-conscious | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker | Frigidaire saves you $92 for similar daily output. |
| Party host | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle | EUHOMY's 34 lbs and nugget ice impress guests. |
| Nugget ice lover | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle | Only EUHOMY makes chewable sonic ice. |
| Small counter | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle | EUHOMY's footprint is 11.6" x 9.5" vs 12" x 11". |
| Energy saver | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker | EUHOMY uses 15.6W vs 105W — a huge difference. |
| High rating seeker | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker | Frigidaire has 4.4 stars vs 4.1. |
| Frequent maintenance avoider | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle | EUHOMY self-cleans; Frigidaire requires manual cleaning. |
Frigidaire saves you $92 for similar daily output.
EUHOMY's 34 lbs and nugget ice impress guests.
Only EUHOMY makes chewable sonic ice.
EUHOMY's footprint is 11.6" x 9.5" vs 12" x 11".
EUHOMY uses 15.6W vs 105W — a huge difference.
Frigidaire has 4.4 stars vs 4.1.
EUHOMY self-cleans; Frigidaire requires manual cleaning.
What if neither is right?
Frigidaire EFIC120-BLKSS-SC Stainless Steel Countertop Ice Maker
$69.99
Same 26 lbs capacity as the budget pick, in a sleeker black stainless finish.
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine with Handle (Bullet Ice)
$89.99
Bullet ice at 26 lbs daily with auto-cleaning for just $90.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frigidaire vs EUHOMY: which ice maker is better?
The Frigidaire wins for budget buyers — $69.99 for 26 lbs of bullet ice daily with fast 7-minute cycles. The EUHOMY takes the lead for nugget ice lovers with 34 lbs capacity, self-cleaning, and lower energy use at $136.77. Your choice depends on ice type preference and budget.
Is the EUHOMY worth $136.77?
Yes, if you value chewable nugget ice and self-cleaning. It produces 34 lbs daily — enough for parties — and uses only 15.6W, saving electricity. Budget shoppers can save $92 with the Frigidaire and get similar bullet ice capacity.
Which ice maker is easier to clean?
The EUHOMY has a self-cleaning function — just hold a button for 3 seconds. The Frigidaire requires manual cleaning via a drain plug. EUHOMY also has a removable top cover for deeper cleaning.
How much counter space does each need?
Frigidaire: 12"D x 11"W x 14.5"H. EUHOMY: 11.6"D x 9.5"W x 13"H. Despite higher capacity, the EUHOMY has a smaller footprint.
Do these ice makers keep the ice frozen?
No — both are countertop models designed to produce ice, not store it. Ice melts in the basket; the water is recycled for the next batch. Transfer ice to your freezer promptly.
How we compared. We analyzed 33,570 verified Amazon reviews and manufacturer specifications across two top-rated ice makers. Prices update weekly from Amazon.
Primary sources. Exact listing details were checked against Amazon US product listing (B0CXZR6HQB); Amazon US product listing (B0C32SGKMJ); Manufacturer product page. Product-family context comes from the linked manufacturer pages; prices, stock, ratings, and review counts are volatile registry fields and should be checked again before purchase.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team. Independent US-market consumer research. Picks reflect editorial consensus from verified buyer reviews and manufacturer data. Prices update weekly from Amazon.