Prices verified May 28 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer wins for budget-conscious buyers — an 800W motor and 3-year warranty at $74.95. The Breville JE98XL wins for performance: 850W, dual speeds, and a trusted brand at $149.95.
The Verdict
Winner
Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer
Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer vs Breville JE98XL Juice Fountain Plus, side by side
Pros:
- 3-inch chute fits whole apples and carrots
- 800W motor handles hard produce
- 3-year warranty is industry-leading
- Dishwasher-safe parts simplify cleanup
Cons (honest weight):
- Single-speed limits versatility
- Plastic build feels less premium
- Louder than some competitors
Pros:
- 850W motor provides powerful extraction
- Two speeds optimize for soft and hard produce
- Higher 4.5 rating from 16k+ reviews
- Compact footprint for its capacity
Cons (honest weight):
- 1-year warranty is shorter than Hamilton Beach
- More expensive at $149.95
- Juice jug is 35 oz, smaller than some competitors
Where each one wins
10 dimensions scored head-to-head. Hamilton Beach takes 4; Breville JE98XL takes 3.
| Dimension | Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer | Breville JE98XL Juice Fountain Plus | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceHamilton Beach saves $75 upfront. | $74.95 | $149.95 | Hamilton Beach |
| Motor PowerBreville's 50W edge provides slightly better extraction. | 800W | 850W | Breville JE98XL |
| SpeedsBreville's dual speeds optimize for different produce. | 1 | 2 | Breville JE98XL |
| WarrantyHamilton Beach offers triple the coverage. | 3 years | 1 year | Hamilton Beach |
| RatingBreville edges ahead by 0.1 stars. | 4.4 | 4.5 | Breville JE98XL |
| Review CountHamilton Beach has 2.5x more user feedback. | 41,272 | 16,669 | Hamilton Beach |
| Feed ChuteBoth accept whole fruits. | 3 inches | 3 inches | Tie |
| WeightHamilton Beach is lighter and easier to move. | 8.4 lbs | 10.1 lbs | Hamilton Beach |
| Pulp Bin CapacityBoth handle large batches. | 80 oz | 2.6 qt (83 oz) | Tie |
| Dishwasher SafeBoth offer easy cleanup. | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| Overall | 4 wins | 3 wins | Hamilton Beach |
Price — Hamilton Beach wins on value
At $74.95, the Hamilton Beach costs half the Breville. That's a $75 savings that covers a year's worth of produce.
The Breville's $149.95 price includes its dual-speed control and higher wattage. If you juice daily, the extra features may justify the premium.
Budget buyers should stick with Hamilton Beach. You get 90% of the performance for half the money.
Motor Power — Breville takes the edge
The Breville's 850W motor is 50W stronger than Hamilton Beach's 800W. That translates to faster juicing of dense carrots, beets, and ginger.
Hamilton Beach's 800W still handles most produce well. In our review analysis, users report satisfactory performance with apples and celery.
If you juice hard vegetables daily, the extra power matters. Occasional users won't notice the difference.
Speeds — Breville's dual-speed is more versatile
Breville offers two speeds: low for soft fruits, high for hard veggies. This allows you to optimize extraction and reduce foaming.
Hamilton Beach has a single speed. It works, but you can't slow down for berries or speed up for carrots.
Speed control benefits those who juice a variety of produce. If you mostly juice apples and carrots, one speed is enough.
Warranty — Hamilton Beach leads by three years
Hamilton Beach backs its juicer with a 3-year warranty. That's three times longer than Breville's 1-year coverage.
A longer warranty signals confidence in build quality. It also saves you repair or replacement costs down the road.
If you want peace of mind, Hamilton Beach is the safer bet. The Breville's shorter warranty is a notable drawback.
Rating & Reviews — Breville scores slightly higher
Breville holds a 4.5-star average from 16,669 reviews. Users praise its juice quality, ease of use, and motor power.
Hamilton Beach has 4.4 stars from 41,272 reviews. The larger sample size adds reliability to the score.
Both are well-regarded. The 0.1 difference is negligible in practical use.
Weight & Portability — Hamilton Beach is lighter
Hamilton Beach weighs 8.4 lbs vs Breville's 10.1 lbs. That's a 1.7 lb difference, noticeable if you store it in a cabinet.
Breville's extra weight comes from its larger motor and metal components. It feels more substantial on the counter.
For small kitchens, the lighter Hamilton Beach is easier to move. Both have cord storage for tidy countertops.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Best value for money | Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer | Hamilton Beach delivers 90% of performance at half the price. |
| Daily heavy juicing | Breville JE98XL Juice Fountain Plus | Breville's 850W motor and dual speeds handle dense produce efficiently. |
| First-time juicer | Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer | Lower price and longer warranty reduce risk for beginners. |
| Small kitchen / limited storage | Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer | Lighter weight and smaller footprint make it easier to stow. |
| Variety of produce (berries + roots) | Breville JE98XL Juice Fountain Plus | Dual speeds let you switch between soft and hard items. |
| Long-term investment | Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer | Three-year warranty provides longer coverage and peace of mind. |
Hamilton Beach delivers 90% of performance at half the price.
Breville's 850W motor and dual speeds handle dense produce efficiently.
Lower price and longer warranty reduce risk for beginners.
Lighter weight and smaller footprint make it easier to stow.
Dual speeds let you switch between soft and hard items.
Three-year warranty provides longer coverage and peace of mind.
What if neither is right?
Breville BJE200XL Juice Fountain Compact
$65.21
A compact, budget-friendly Breville with a 700W motor and 3-inch chute, perfect for tight spaces.
Elite Gourmet ETS623 Electric Citrus Juicer
$13.99
If you only juice citrus, this $14 model is a no-brainer — 4.5 stars from 6,738 reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Hamilton Beach vs Breville: which juicer is better?
The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer is better for most budget-minded buyers due to its $75 price, 3-year warranty, and solid 800W performance. The Breville JE98XL is better for those who want more power, dual speeds, and a higher rating. Choose based on your budget and juicing frequency.
Is the Breville JE98XL worth the extra $75?
It depends on your needs. If you juice daily and want speed control for different produce, the extra $75 gets you 50W more power and two speeds. If you juice occasionally, the Hamilton Beach delivers comparable results at half the price.
Which juicer has a longer warranty?
The Hamilton Beach comes with a 3-year limited warranty, while the Breville JE98XL has a 1-year warranty. Hamilton Beach's coverage is three times longer, offering better long-term peace of mind.
Are both juicers easy to clean?
Yes, both have dishwasher-safe removable parts. The Hamilton Beach includes a cleaning brush for the strainer. The Breville's parts are also dishwasher-safe. Expect about 5 minutes of cleanup per use for either model.
Which juicer handles whole fruits better?
Both have a 3-inch wide feed chute that fits whole apples, carrots, and celery without pre-cutting. Users of both models report minimal prep time. The Breville's dual speeds give it an edge with leafy greens and soft berries.
What do Wirecutter and Consumer Reports say about these juicers?
Wirecutter recommends the Nama J3 as their top overall juicer but notes that centrifugal models like these are great for speed. Consumer Reports testing emphasizes that wider chutes and higher wattage improve convenience. Neither specifically reviews these two models head-to-head, but both highlight value and ease of cleaning as key factors.
How we compared. We analyzed 57,941 verified Amazon reviews, cross-referenced expert verdicts from Wirecutter and Consumer Reports, and compared manufacturer specifications. Prices update weekly from Amazon.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team — independent US-market consumer research. Picks reflect analysis from 2 independent review sources and 57,941+ verified buyer reviews.