HP 58A
(CF258A) Black Original Toner Cartridge
Price as of 2026-07-26. Check Amazon for the current price.
Quick Decision
Price Intelligence
- Budget:$24–$59
- Mid-range:$59–$154← You are here
- Premium:$154+
Is This Right For You?
- •Buyers who prioritize quality over price in Printer Toner
- •Those who want a top-rated option — in the top 1% of Printer Toner by rating
- •HP loyalists — the brand spans 24 products in our database
- •You're on a tight budget — $39 above the category average of $108
- •HP 206A Black Toner Cartridge — 42% cheaper at $85 (Score A-)
📊 Based on data analysis of 16 products in this category.
Mubboo Score: B
How we calculate the Mubboo Score
Quality (45%): customer rating, normalized to a 10-point scale
Popularity (35%): review volume vs the category leader, log-scaled
Value (20%): price position vs other Printer Toner
Computed from live Amazon rating, review count, and price across 16 Printer Toner available to US consumers · last refreshed 2026-07-26.
How It Compares
This Product HP 58A | Most Popular Brother TN760 2-Pack High-Yield Toner Cartridge | Best Rated HP 206A Black Toner Cartridge | Best Value TRUE IMAGE 206X Toner Cartridges 4 Pack High Yield: MFP | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $146.89 | $176.49 | $84.89 | $89.94 |
| Rating | 4.7/5 | 4.7/5 | 4.7/5 | 4.4/5 |
| Reviews | 3,129 | 34,531 | 5,233 | 789 |
| Mubboo Score | B | A- | A- | B |
Quick Specs
- Color
- Black
- Duplex
- Simplex
- Ink Colour
- Black
- Page Yield
- 3000
- Unit Count
- 1.0 Count
- Item Weight
- 1 Pounds
- Print media
- Paper (plain)
- Manufacturer
- HP
What buyers say about Printer Toner
Themes from buyer reviews across this category — not review data for this specific model.
Choose genuine OEM toner for reliable performance and print quality, despite the higher cost. Expect low-toner warnings to appear prematurely, but you can often print many more pages beyond them.
- Print Quality
- Reliability and Consistent Performance
- Longevity and High Page Yield
- OEM Advantage Over Compatibles
- Value Despite High Cost
- High Price
- Premature Low-Toner Warnings and Optimistic Page Yield
Expert Picks in Printer Toner
- Comp and Save Compatible Toner (HP 206A 4-pack) — Cost-conscious home and small-office users replacing HP and Brother cartridges
- HP 206A Compatible 4-Pack (Black/Cyan/Magenta/Yellow) — HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP owners needing full CMYK replacement
- Brother TN730 Compatible Mono Toner — High-volume mono printing on Brother compact laser printers
- HP 414X High-Yield 4-Pack (CMYK) — Heavy-duty color printing on HP Color LaserJet Pro M454 / M479 series
- Brother TN830XL High-Yield Mono — Home office users on newer Brother HL-L2460DW / MFC-L2820DW
- Canon CRG-069H High-Yield 4-Pack — Canon imageCLASS MF751 / MF753 color laser users
Category recommendations from independent expert publications. Source links in References.
Related Video Reviews
- 📹 Best Ink For Laser Printer 2026: Top 12 Toner Cartridges for Sharp, Cost-Effective Prints — Printer repair expert (Josh)
Key Features
- ✦HP Ink Cartridges are engineered to work with HP printers to provide consistent quality, reliability and value
- ✦Works with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw
- ✦Cartridge yield (approx.): 3,000 pages
- ✦Use HP Toner Cartridges to eliminate toner leaks and premature failures
- ✦88% of HP ink cartridges are manufactured with recycled plastic
Source: product listing on Amazon.
About HP
- 24 products in our database
- Average rating: 4.2/5 across all products
- Price range: $26.89 – $637
- Categories: 2-in-1-laptops, Inkjet Printers, Laptops, Laser Printers, Printer Ink Cartridges, printers-and-accessories
If not the 58A, consider these
Featured in Our Reviews
Bottom Line
HP 58A earns Mubboo Score B. Priced at $147 — a premium option, above the category average of $108. Rated 4.7/5 from 3,129+ reviews. Strong buy if: buyers who prioritize quality over price in printer toner, those who want a top-rated option. Skip if: you're on a tight budget — Brother TN760 2-Pack High-Yield Toner Cartridge (Score A-, $176) may fit better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the HP 58A worth buying in 2026?
It earns a Mubboo Score of B, with a 4.7/5 rating from 3,129 reviews — better than 100% of Printer Toner we track.
How much does the HP 58A cost?
It is currently $146.89 — premium-tier pricing for Printer Toner.
How does the 58A compare to other Printer Toner?
The category's most-reviewed alternative is the Brother TN760 2-Pack High-Yield Toner Cartridge (4.7/5, 34,531 reviews, $176.49). The 58A carries a Mubboo Score of B vs A-.
Sources & References
- View on Amazon →
- topconsumerreviews review →
- mycartridge review →
- tonerbuzz review →
- Browse all Printer Toner on Mubboo →
Products available through US retailers. Prices in USD. Sales tax varies by state and is not included.
Mubboo may earn a commission on purchases made through affiliate links. This does not affect our Mubboo Score, product rankings, or editorial judgments. Prices are accurate as of the last sync (2026-07-26) and may change.