Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed
Veal 10.5 D (M)
Price as of 2026-06-03. Check Amazon for the current price.
Quick Decision
Price Intelligence
- Budget:$32–$49
- Mid-range:$49–$106
- Premium:$106+← You are here
Is This Right For You?
- •Buyers who prioritize quality over price in Mens Dress Shoes
- •You're on a tight budget — $106 above the category average of $89
- •Rating sits in the bottom 21% of Mens Dress Shoes — higher-rated options exist
- •Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe offers a better rating (4.6/5) at a similar or lower price ($104)
- •Rockport mens Style Leader 2 Apron Toe oxfords shoes — 54% cheaper at $90 (Score B)
- •Florsheim mens Medfield Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe — higher rated at 4.7/5 ($100)
📊 Based on data analysis of 75 products in this category.
Mubboo Score: C+
How we calculate the Mubboo Score
Quality (45%): customer rating, normalized to a 10-point scale
Popularity (35%): review volume vs the category leader, log-scaled
Value (20%): price position vs other Mens Dress Shoes
Computed from live Amazon rating, review count, and price across 75 Mens Dress Shoes available to US consumers · last refreshed 2026-06-03.
How It Compares
This Product Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed | Most Popular Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe | Best Rated Florsheim mens Medfield Cap Toe Oxford Dress Shoe | Best Value Rockport mens Style Leader 2 Apron Toe oxfords shoes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $194.95 | $104 | $99.95 | $89.95 |
| Rating | 4.4/5 | 4.6/5 | 4.7/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Reviews | 832 | 10,091 | 1,844 | 2,491 |
| Mubboo Score | C+ | B+ | B | B |
What People Say
Synthesized from 40 reviews · 100% verified purchases.
Check sizing carefully as some styles run large or narrow; these shoes deliver great comfort and style for the price but may not hold up to daily heavy use over years.
- Attractive/Stylish Design
- Exceptional Comfort
- Great Value for Money
- Good Quality Construction
- Accurate/Consistent Sizing
- Sizing Variability
- Limited Longevity
- Break-in Period Required
Related Video Reviews
If not the Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed, consider these
Bottom Line
Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed earns Mubboo Score C+. Priced at $195 — a premium option, above the category average of $89. Rated 4.4/5 from 832+ reviews. Strong buy if: buyers who prioritize quality over price in mens dress shoes. Skip if: you're on a tight budget — Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe (Score B+, $104) may fit better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed worth buying in 2026?
It earns a Mubboo Score of C+, with a 4.4/5 rating from 832 reviews — better than 21% of Mens Dress Shoes we track.
How much does the Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed cost?
It is currently $194.95 — premium-tier pricing for Mens Dress Shoes.
How does the Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed compare to other Mens Dress Shoes?
The category's most-reviewed alternative is the Cole Haan Men's Original Grand Shortwing Oxford Shoe (4.6/5, 10,091 reviews, $104). The Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford Black Brushed carries a Mubboo Score of C+ vs B+.
Sources & References
Products available through US retailers. Prices in USD. Sales tax varies by state and is not included.
Mubboo may earn a commission on purchases made through affiliate links. This does not affect our Mubboo Score, product rankings, or editorial judgments. Prices are accurate as of the last sync (2026-06-03) and may change.