Cottonelle Ultra Clean Toilet Paper Review: Is the 132-Roll Family Mega Pack Worth $44.99?

The Active CleaningRipples texture is the reason to choose this pack over a flat 1-ply sheet. Raised ridges run across each sheet, adding surface contact that a smooth Scott ComfortPlus sheet doesn't offer at a similar thickness.

On a Monday morning when four people cycle through one bathroom before school and work, texture matters more than sheet count — a ridged sheet clears in fewer wipes than a flat one at the same weight.

The trade-off: Charmin Ultra Soft skips texture entirely and leans on a cushioned 2-ply layer instead. Buyers who want a soft, cloud-like feel over a cleaning-focused ridge pattern will prefer Charmin's approach.

This box holds 24 Family Mega Rolls, which Cottonelle states equals 132 regular rolls — working out to roughly $0.34 per regular-roll equivalent at the current $44.99 price.

Charmin Ultra Soft's comparable 24 Family Mega box claims 123 regular rolls for $35.49, or about $0.29 per roll — roughly 15% cheaper per roll than this Cottonelle pack despite the similar bulk format.

Scott ComfortPlus takes a different approach with 12 Triple Rolls at 231 sheets each. Per 100 sheets, Scott runs about $0.20 versus roughly $0.48 for this Cottonelle pack — the widest price gap in the lineup, though Scott skips the ripple texture entirely.

For a household of two to three that reorders every 6-8 weeks, the $0.34-per-roll rate is reasonable if the texture upgrade matters; heavier stockpilers chasing the lowest per-sheet cost should start with Scott instead.

This pack is 1-ply construction, the same base as Scott ComfortPlus. It is not the 2-ply cushioned sheet that Charmin Ultra Soft uses, and buyers coming from a 2-ply household will notice the difference in hand within the first roll.

During a late-night bathroom run when nobody wants to think about paper thickness, the ridge texture largely compensates for the thinner base sheet — but it doesn't fully close the comfort gap with a true 2-ply product.

The 113,691 ratings behind this pack's 4.8-star average suggest most buyers accept this trade-off at this price point, but anyone upgrading specifically for softness should look at Charmin Ultra Soft first.

A 24-roll box this size needs real storage space — expect to dedicate a closet shelf or under-sink bin, especially if you're also stocking Scott ComfortPlus or another bulk brand alongside it.

This ASIN is not Prime-eligible, which means shipping speed and any delivery fee depend on the seller arrangement at checkout rather than standard 2-day Prime shipping — worth checking before you add it to a routine reorder.

The 1-ply sheet also breaks down faster in water than a thicker 2-ply roll, which is generally the safer profile for households running an older or sensitive septic system.

If you're stocking up ahead of a holiday weekend with houseguests, budget an extra day or two for delivery given the non-Prime status, rather than ordering the morning guests arrive.

Weight is another factor worth planning around: a 132-regular-roll box is bulky and heavy to carry in from the porch, so consider where the delivery will land before it arrives.

This pack carries a 4.8-star average across 113,691 verified ratings, one of the highest review volumes in the toilet paper category on Amazon, and sits at #134 in Amazon's Health & Household best-seller rank.

For context, Scott ComfortPlus carries 145,040 ratings at 4.6 stars, and Charmin Ultra Soft carries 126,664 ratings at 4.8 stars — all three products cluster in the same high-volume, high-rating range typical of daily household staples.

When you're standing in a warehouse-club aisle comparing bulk boxes side by side, a track record like this — six figures of ratings holding steady at 4.6-4.8 stars across three competing brands — is easier to trust than an unfamiliar store brand with only a handful of reviews.