Prices verified Aug 8 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
Quick answer
MaxxHaul is the better fit for an open steel basket: the current US registry lists model 70115 at $109.99, 46 by 36 by 4.5 inches, 25 pounds, alloy steel, crossbar mounting, and a 150-pound product load capacity. FIVKLEMNZ is the better fit for enclosed soft-bag storage: the registry lists $71.99, 21 cubic feet, 52 by 40 by 17 inches, Oxford cloth, roof mounting, and a waterproof rating. The FIVKLEMNZ manufacturer describes a 52 by 40 by 18 inch soft bag that can be installed with or without a roof rack, but this does not override your vehicle's roof limit or the exact product instructions. MaxxHaul's 150-pound rating is the basket's product limit, not a vehicle load recommendation. Choose by cargo shape, enclosed-versus-open format, existing crossbars, storage needs, and vehicle compatibility. Review counts are marketplace context, not proof of safe loading, weather performance, durability, fuel economy, or universal fit.
Choose MaxxHaul for an open steel basket with a 150-pound product rating; choose FIVKLEMNZ for a 21-cubic-foot soft roof bag. Check vehicle, crossbar, attachment, clearance, and weather limits before loading.
Mubboo Verdict
Best for most people
MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket
It is the better fit when you already have compatible crossbars and need an open basket for bulky or rigid cargo.
Pick the FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier instead if
- You want enclosed soft-bag storage instead of an open basket.
- Your vehicle passes the exact roof, door-hook, clearance, and attachment checks.
- You prefer 21 cubic feet of listed bag volume and a $20 lower current registry price.
- You accept the manufacturer's caveat that waterproof performance is not guaranteed in extreme weather or improper use.
MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket vs FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier, side by side
MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket
Pros:
- Lower current registry price gap is only $20
- Registry lists alloy-steel construction and 46 by 36 by 4.5 inch dimensions
- Registry lists 150-pound product load capacity
- Open basket format suits bulky or rigid cargo better than a soft enclosed bag
- MaxxHaul manual identifies roof-rack crossbars as the mounting surface
Cons (honest weight):
- Requires compatible crossbars
- Open format does not enclose cargo from weather
- 150 pounds is the product rating, not a vehicle or crossbar load recommendation
FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier
Pros:
- $20 lower current registry price than MaxxHaul
- Registry lists 21 cubic feet and a 52 by 40 by 17 inch format
- Registry lists Oxford cloth, roof mounting, and a waterproof rating
- Manufacturer describes with-or-without-rack installation with straps and door hooks
- Soft format can be stored more easily between trips than a steel basket
Cons (honest weight):
- Soft bag is not the same format as a rigid open basket
- Manufacturer limits waterproof claims for extreme weather or improper use
- Vehicle roof, door-hook, clearance, and attachment limits still require independent verification
Where each one wins
8 dimensions scored head-to-head. MaxxHaul 70115 takes 0; FIVKLEMNZ 21 takes 3.
| Dimension | MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket | FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current registry priceFIVKLEMNZ is $20 lower in the current registry; prices can change. | $109.99 | $71.99 | FIVKLEMNZ 21 |
| Carrier formatChoose the cargo format before comparing price or ratings. | Open alloy-steel basket | Soft enclosed roof bag | Tie |
| Listed load or volumeThese are different measurements; neither is a vehicle roof limit or a guarantee of usable loading. | 150 lb product load capacity | 21 cu ft listed volume | Tie |
| MountingVerify the exact vehicle, crossbars, door hooks, attachment points, clearance, and instructions. | Crossbar mount | Roof mount; manufacturer describes with-or-without-rack setup | Tie |
| Weather protectionFIVKLEMNZ is the enclosed format, but waterproof performance is not absolute in every condition. | Open basket; no enclosure | Waterproof rating in registry; manufacturer caveat applies | FIVKLEMNZ 21 |
| Product size and weightThe basket is lower profile; the bag provides more listed volume but extends higher. | 46 by 36 by 4.5 in; 25 lb | 52 by 40 by 17 in; 4.68 kg | Tie |
| Storage between tripsThe soft bag is the easier format to fold or store, subject to the live instructions. | Rigid steel basket | Soft bag format | FIVKLEMNZ 21 |
| Vehicle-limit boundaryThe lowest applicable vehicle, roof, crossbar, attachment, or carrier limit controls. | 150 lb is product rating only | No vehicle load limit supplied by this comparison | Tie |
| Overall | 0 wins | 3 wins | FIVKLEMNZ 21 |
Start With the Carrier Format
MaxxHaul and FIVKLEMNZ solve different loading problems. MaxxHaul is an open steel basket that needs compatible crossbars. FIVKLEMNZ is a soft enclosed roof bag with a listed 21-cubic-foot volume.
Choose open versus enclosed first, then check price, fitment, cargo shape, storage, and weather needs.
Current Price and Product Limits
The current US registry lists MaxxHaul at $109.99 and FIVKLEMNZ at $71.99. The $20 gap is smaller than the cost of a wrong fitment decision.
MaxxHaul's registry row lists a 150-pound product load capacity. That number applies to the basket as a product rating; it does not override the lower limit from the vehicle roof, crossbars, attachment hardware, or manufacturer instructions.
Mounting and Vehicle Fit
MaxxHaul's registry and manual identify roof-rack crossbars as the mounting surface. Confirm the crossbar spacing, width, attachment hardware, clearance, and the vehicle's roof limit.
FIVKLEMNZ's manufacturer describes installation with or without a roof rack using straps and door hooks. That claim still requires checking the exact vehicle's door seals, hook placement, clearance, roof limit, and live instructions.
Volume and Weather Protection
FIVKLEMNZ lists 21 cubic feet and a waterproof rating. Its manufacturer page describes a 700D PVC soft bag, heat-sealed seams, and a double-layer waterproof cover, but also says extreme weather or improper use can defeat the guarantee.
MaxxHaul is an open basket. It can hold cargo that needs an open platform, but it does not enclose luggage. Use a separately verified cover or weather solution only when the exact product and loading instructions support it.
What Reviews Can and Cannot Tell You
MaxxHaul has 11,701 current registry reviews and FIVKLEMNZ has 8,637. The current ratings are 4.5/5 and 4.4/5.
Those numbers are marketplace context only. They do not establish safe loading, vehicle compatibility, waterproof performance, fuel economy, durability, or theft resistance.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose MaxxHaul when compatible crossbars and an open basket match your cargo. Choose FIVKLEMNZ when an enclosed soft bag and its exact vehicle installation method match your needs.
Before every trip, check the vehicle owner's manual, roof and crossbar limits, carrier instructions, attachment points, clearance, load distribution, and closure or tie-down requirements. The lowest applicable limit controls.
Current In-Stock Alternatives
MeeFar is a current 20-cubic-foot soft-bag alternative. The registry lists B0B1J6WYVZ at $99.99 with a waterproof rating. RoofPax is a larger 28-cubic-foot soft-bag alternative. The registry lists B0CMTLCB8X at $156.80 with a waterproof rating. Verify exact dimensions, vehicle fit, and live price before checkout.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest current price | FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | FIVKLEMNZ is $20 lower in the current registry. |
| Bulky or rigid cargo | MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket | The open steel basket is the better-matched format; verify crossbars and all load limits. |
| Enclosed luggage volume | FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | FIVKLEMNZ is the listed 21-cubic-foot soft-bag format. |
| Already have compatible crossbars | MaxxHaul 70115 Steel Roof Rack Cargo Basket | MaxxHaul's registry and manual identify crossbar mounting. |
| No roof rack | FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | FIVKLEMNZ's manufacturer describes with-or-without-rack installation; verify the exact vehicle and instructions. |
| Weather protection for luggage | FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cu Ft Rooftop Cargo Carrier | FIVKLEMNZ is listed waterproof, with a manufacturer caveat for extreme weather and improper use. |
FIVKLEMNZ is $20 lower in the current registry.
The open steel basket is the better-matched format; verify crossbars and all load limits.
FIVKLEMNZ is the listed 21-cubic-foot soft-bag format.
MaxxHaul's registry and manual identify crossbar mounting.
FIVKLEMNZ's manufacturer describes with-or-without-rack installation; verify the exact vehicle and instructions.
FIVKLEMNZ is listed waterproof, with a manufacturer caveat for extreme weather and improper use.
What if neither is right?
MeeFar Rooftop Cargo Carrier 20 Cubic Feet
$99.99
An in-stock 20-cubic-foot soft bag with a waterproof rating in the current registry; verify the exact dimensions and vehicle fit.
RoofPax XXL 28 CuFt Rooftop Cargo Carrier
$156.80
An in-stock 28-cubic-foot soft bag with a waterproof rating and 52 by 39.37 by 24 inch registry dimensions.
Frequently Asked Questions
MaxxHaul basket vs FIVKLEMNZ bag: which should I buy?
Choose MaxxHaul if you have compatible crossbars and need an open basket for bulky or rigid cargo. Choose FIVKLEMNZ if you need an enclosed 21-cubic-foot soft bag and the exact vehicle, straps, door hooks, clearance, and roof limits fit.
Which roof cargo carrier is cheaper right now?
The current US registry lists MaxxHaul at $109.99 and FIVKLEMNZ at $71.99, a $20 difference. Prices, sellers, variants, and included hardware can change, so verify the live listings.
Does MaxxHaul's 150-pound rating mean my car can carry 150 pounds?
No. The 150-pound figure is the MaxxHaul 70115 product load capacity. Your vehicle roof, crossbars, attachment hardware, and carrier instructions may impose lower limits. Use the lowest applicable limit.
Do I need a roof rack for these carriers?
MaxxHaul's registry and manual identify crossbars as the mounting surface. FIVKLEMNZ's manufacturer describes with-or-without-rack installation using straps and door hooks, but you must verify your exact vehicle, door seals, clearance, roof limit, and instructions.
Is the FIVKLEMNZ bag really waterproof?
The current registry lists a waterproof rating, and the manufacturer describes a waterproof cover and welded construction. The same manufacturer limits the claim for extreme weather or improper use, so treat it as a product claim with conditions, not an absolute guarantee.
Can I use MaxxHaul for lumber or sharp tools?
MaxxHaul is the open-basket format and may be the better format for bulky or rigid cargo, but this article does not certify a particular load. Check the exact basket, cargo restraints, crossbar rating, vehicle roof limit, clearance, and owner instructions before carrying anything.
Will either carrier fit my SUV?
Neither product is universally confirmed for every SUV by this comparison. Check roof type, crossbar spacing, door seals, attachment points, clearance, roof limit, and the exact carrier instructions for your vehicle. Marketplace review counts are not fitment evidence.
What are good alternatives?
MeeFar B0B1J6WYVZ is an in-stock 20-cubic-foot soft bag listed at $99.99. RoofPax B0CMTLCB8X is an in-stock 28-cubic-foot soft bag listed at $156.80. Verify the current dimensions, fitment, and vehicle limits before checkout.
How we compared. We used current US registry rows for volatile data; MaxxHaul's official manual and shop for crossbar and product-limit context; and FIVKLEMNZ's first-party page for mounting and weather caveats. We do not claim hands-on vehicle-fit, fuel-economy, weather, or loading tests.
Primary sources. Exact listing details were checked against Amazon US product listing (B073G49NPV); Amazon US product listing (B0BCW2CD2R). Product-family context comes from the linked manufacturer pages; prices, stock, ratings, and review counts are volatile registry fields and should be checked again before purchase.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team. Independent US-market consumer research. We separate product ratings from vehicle fitment and keep roof, crossbar, attachment, clearance, and loading limits visible.