Prices verified May 28 · Always confirm at the retailer before buying.
The DEWALT TSTAK Extra Large Tool Box wins for most workshops — 22.71L capacity and a removable tray justify the $11 premium over the TSTAK II Flat Top.
The Verdict
Winner
DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray
DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray vs DEWALT TSTAK II Flat Top Tool Storage Case, side by side
Pros:
- 22.71L volume for large tool storage
- 44 lb max load capacity
- Removable tray for quick access to small items
- Stackable with other TSTAK units
- Bi-material handle for comfortable carry
Cons (honest weight):
- No wheels for easy transport
- Plastic blend may not be as durable as metal
Pros:
- 66 lb max load supports heavy tools
- Lightweight 3.77 lbs, easy to carry
- Flat top design for stable stacking
- Heavy-duty metal latches resist rust
- Limited lifetime warranty
Cons (honest weight):
- Discontinued by manufacturer (limited availability)
- No removable tray for small parts
Where each one wins
9 dimensions scored head-to-head. DEWALT TSTAK takes 4; DEWALT TSTAK takes 3.
| Dimension | DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray | DEWALT TSTAK II Flat Top Tool Storage Case | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| PriceTSTAK II is $11.26 cheaper | $34.85 | $23.59 | DEWALT TSTAK |
| Capacity (L)Extra Large holds much more volume | 22.71L | — | DEWALT TSTAK |
| Max Load (lbs)TSTAK II supports 50% more weight | 44 lbs | 66 lbs | DEWALT TSTAK |
| Weight (lbs)Extra Large is lighter to carry when empty | 16 oz (1 lb) | 3.77 lbs | DEWALT TSTAK |
| PortabilityTSTAK II is easier to transport | No wheels, bi-material handle | Lightweight, flat top for stacking | DEWALT TSTAK |
| StackabilityBoth work with the TSTAK system | TSTAK compatible | TSTAK compatible | Tie |
| WarrantySame warranty coverage | Limited lifetime | Limited lifetime | Tie |
| Dimensions (inches)Extra Large is taller for deeper storage | 17.3 x 11.9 x 13 | 16.93 x 12.99 x 5.91 | DEWALT TSTAK |
| Rating (out of 5)Extra Large has higher verified rating | 4.8 | 4.7 | DEWALT TSTAK |
| Overall | 4 wins | 3 wins | DEWALT TSTAK |
Price — TSTAK II wins on value
The TSTAK II Flat Top costs $23.59, $11.26 less than the Extra Large. That savings matters for budget-conscious buyers who don't need maximum volume.
For the Extra Large, the $34.85 price is still competitive. It costs less per liter than comparable stackable boxes from other brands.
Capacity — Extra Large dominates
6.00 gallons vs. an unspecified figure for the TSTAK II. The Extra Large holds enough for a full set of power tools and accessories.
The removable tray inside the Extra Large adds organization. Small bits stay separate from bulk tools, a feature the TSTAK II lacks.
Max Load — TSTAK II carries more weight
66 lbs max load on the TSTAK II vs. 44 lbs on the Extra Large. Despite its lighter build, the TSTAK II can hold heavier items.
If you transport heavy tools like hammers or wrenches, the TSTAK II is the safer bet. The Extra Large is better for lighter, bulkier items.
Portability — TSTAK II is easier to move
Weighing only 3.77 lbs, the TSTAK II is a featherweight. The Extra Large is lighter empty (1 lb) but lacks a flat top for stable stacking during transport.
Both have bi-material handles, but the TSTAK II's flat top and lower profile make it easier to grab and go.
Stackability — Identical system
Both boxes are part of the DEWALT TSTAK modular system. They latch together with side latches and stack on any TSTAK base.
You can mix and match these boxes with drawers, organizers, and rolling carts.
Warranty — Equal protection
Both come with a limited lifetime warranty from DEWALT. That covers manufacturing defects but not normal wear.
For long-term investment, this warranty adds peace of mind for both models.
Dimensions — Extra Large offers depth
The Extra Large is 13 inches tall vs. 5.91 inches for the TSTAK II. That extra height accommodates larger tools like drills and saws.
The TSTAK II's shallow depth (5.91 in) is better for maximizing horizontal packing.
Rating — Extra Large leads by 0.1 stars
4.8 stars from 12,355 reviews vs. 4.7 stars from 11,704 reviews. Both are highly regarded, but the Extra Large edges ahead in customer satisfaction.
Common praise for both includes build quality and stackability.
Which should you buy?
| Your situation | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Large workshop storage | DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray | Extra Large holds more bulk tools |
| Jobsite portability | DEWALT TSTAK II Flat Top Tool Storage Case | Lightweight and flat top for easy carrying |
| Budget-conscious buyer | DEWALT TSTAK II Flat Top Tool Storage Case | Lower price, same system compatibility |
| Stackable system builder | DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray | Both work with TSTAK system |
| Heavy tool transport | DEWALT TSTAK II Flat Top Tool Storage Case | Higher max load (66 lbs) |
| Everyday DIY | DEWALT TSTAK Tool Box, Extra Large Design, Removable Tray | Removable tray organizes small parts |
Extra Large holds more bulk tools
Lightweight and flat top for easy carrying
Lower price, same system compatibility
Both work with TSTAK system
Higher max load (66 lbs)
Removable tray organizes small parts
What if neither is right?
DEWALT TSTAK Double Drawer Tool Storage Organizer
$35.97
Two drawers for small bits and accessories
DEWALT TSTAK Rolling Tool Box with Telescopic Handle
$88.43
Mobile storage with 7-inch wheels and telescopic handle
Frequently Asked Questions
DEWALT TSTAK Extra Large vs TSTAK II Flat Top: which is better?
It depends on your needs. The Extra Large is better for fixed workshop storage with its 22.71L capacity and removable tray. The TSTAK II is lighter (3.77 lbs) and supports more weight (66 lbs), making it ideal for jobsite portability.
Is the DEWALT TSTAK II worth the lower price?
Yes, if you prioritize portability and budget. At $23.59, it offers a 66 lb max load, heavy-duty latches, and full TSTAK compatibility. You lose the removable tray and some depth, but save $11.26.
Can I stack the TSTAK Extra Large with other TSTAK units?
Absolutely. Both the Extra Large and TSTAK II are part of the DEWALT TSTAK modular system. They latch together with side latches and stack on any TSTAK base, including rolling carts and drawer units.
What is the warranty on these DEWALT tool boxes?
Both models come with a limited lifetime warranty from DEWALT. It covers manufacturing defects but not normal wear or abuse. Register your product for full coverage details.
Are these tool boxes water resistant?
The Extra Large TSTAK is rated water resistant from the manufacturer. The TSTAK II does not carry a water resistance rating, but its metal latches and plastic body offer some splash protection.
How we compared. We analyzed 24,059 verified Amazon reviews and manufacturer specifications for both DEWALT TSTAK models. Prices update weekly from Amazon.
Who wrote this and where's the data from?
Mubboo Editorial Team — independent US-market consumer research. Picks reflect editorial analysis of verified buyer reviews and product specifications.