12 photosSicily Osteria
4.8/5 — Excellent(1,930 reviews)· $$· Italian, Pizza, Sicilian· New York
Mubboo Verdict
Lively Italian spot near theaters, loved by families and groups for its service and outdoor seating.
Insider tip: The reviews repeatedly name Roberto as a standout server, suggesting the staff personality is a key reason for the high rating, not just the food.
★ TravelFit — Who this spot suits
Tap a traveler type to see how well it fits.
Date night
82/100High atmosphere rating (4.8) and full bar make it good for a date, though 23% couples trips suggest it's not the top focus.
- trip_types: Couples 23%
- amenities: full bar, wine
- subratings: Atmosphere 4.8
Plan your visit
Price$$
Best timepost Broadway show
AreaNew York
📍 328 W 46th St 330, New York City, New York 10036-8390
Ratings
4.8/5Excellent· 1,930 reviews
- Food
- 4.8
- Value
- 4.7
- Service
- 4.9
- Atmosphere
- 4.8
★ What reviewers say
✅ Diners love
- Friendly staff (especially Roberto)
- Outdoor sidewalk seating
- Great for post-theater dinner
⚠ Watch out for
- No specific drawbacks mentioned in reviews
- Can be busy near theater district
- Limited info on pricing or wait times
★ Real traveler reviews
Verbatim excerpts from TripAdvisor reviews.
★★★★★Family
“Food was great and staff were very friendly”
★★★★★Friends getaway
“This was such an amazing spot to stop into post Broadway show. Roberto was amazing and we were able to sit outside and enjoy the beautiful nyc summer day. Highly recommend!”
★★★★★Family
“The food, atmosphere, and waitstaff were perfect. Sidewalk seating on a beautiful June night—can’t beat it!”
★★★★★Family
“Roberto was lovely - very attentive and polite. He made great recommendations, and the atmosphere was perfect for a ladies night out.”
🎟 Things to do nearby
Similar restaurants
Frequently asked questions
Is Sicily Osteria worth it?▾
Lively Italian spot near theaters, loved by families and groups for its service and outdoor seating.
What's the best time to visit Sicily Osteria?▾
post Broadway show